Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (2024)

6 Comments Affiliate Disclosure

942 Shares

Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (1)

I never tried making paleo ketchup because I thought it would be impossible to replicate the true flavor of the refined-sugar-laden original. I had perused a few recipes for paleo ketchup and gave it a pass. “Tomato paste flavored with apple cider vinegar?” I thought. “No thanks, I’ll just have my sweet potato fries plain.

Recently, I made some chicken-and-veggie bites (recipe coming!) and knew that ketchup would pair perfectly. So I opened my pantry, threw the most flavorfulingredients I found into a pot, and let it simmer until thick.

After chilling the final paleo ketchup, I couldn’t believe the flavor… it psychically transported me to childhood with my face stuffed ketchup-drenched fries.

This wins the award for the most kid-friendly — and adult-friendly — recipe.

About the Ingredients in Paleo Ketcup

Coconut aminos – This is the secret for rich, umami flavor. In this case, you cannot substitute tamari sauce for the coconut aminos because it will be too salty and strong.

Maple syrup – You can use honey if desired, but I prefer the rich depth of flavor provided by grade B maple syrup. If you peruse other recipes for homemade ketchup, you’ll find that the sweetener levels can be very high. I used a smaller ratio of maple syrup, but it doesn’tleave this ketchup lacking sweetness. If desired, you could probably use only 3 Tbs. of maple syrup.

Dijon mustard – I use thismild Dijon mustard to add tanginess. The resulting ketchup is not sharp or hot, so don’t leave it out this ingredient for concernthat it is not kid-friendly.

Tomato paste and crushed tomatoes – I use the Jovial brand of tomato paste (available here) and crushed tomatoes (available here). The acidic quality of tomatoes can leach chemicals from the lining of cans, so I’m diligent to avoid tomatoes in traditional cans. If you have access to only canned tomatoes, make sure it says, “BPA Free Can.”

Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe

Author:Lauren

Serves:2 cups

This paleo ketchup tastes like the original, but without artificial flavors or refined sugar. It also freezes well. If you make a double batch, you will need to adjust the simmering time to more than 25 minutes (perhaps 35 minutes). Simmer until it is the thickened consistency of regular ketchup.

Ingredients

  • 1 6 or 7 oz. jar of tomato paste, I recommend this one
  • 1 14-to-18 oz. jar of crushed tomatoes, I recommend this one
  • ¼ cup organic maple syrup, available here
  • 3 Tbs. apple cider vinegar
  • 1 Tbs. coconut aminos, available here
  • 1 Tbs. mild dijon mustard, I recommend this one
  • ½ tsp. onion powder, available here
  • ¼ tsp. garlic powder, available here
  • ¾ tsp. unrefined salt, available here

Instructions

  1. Place all ingredients in a blender and process until smooth.
  2. Pour into a saucepan and simmer until thickened to the consistency of ketchup, about 25 minutes. (Be careful of splattering, as the ketchup stains. Keep it on a low simmer.)
  3. Remove from heat and cool until room temperature. Then, put in a covered container and chill.
  4. The ketchup keeps about a week in the fridge, and freezes well.

Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (2)

942 Shares

You may also enjoy

  • Tomato Free Barbecue Sauce
  • 10-Minute Thai Red Curry Soup
  • Turmeric Bombs: DIY Turmeric Supplement
  • 25 Brilliant Three Ingredient Paleo Recipes

Reader Interactions

6 Comments

  1. Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (7)Daina Westman

    Hi Lauren!

    Happy Valentines Day! Red is the appropriate color for the day!

    Tempted to try this recipe, but I’m wondering why use onion and garlic powders when the real thing can be pureed? This might alter the flavor of this recipe, but thought provoking all the same….

    Daina

    reply to this comment

    • Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (8)Lauren

      I think you could substitute a minced clove of garlic, but the flavor might be too strong. The garlic powder is more mild. You could also likely use 1/4 chopped onion, pureed with the rest of the ingredients.

      reply to this comment

  2. Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (9)Elizabeth Resnick

    Thanks Lauren! I’ve never been that big on ketchup, but agree that there are certain foods that pair really well with it. This recipe looks easy enough that I just might give it a go. I’m also thinking it could be mixed with a healthy mayo (I love Primal Kitchen) to make Russian dressing. Which suddenly opens up some new salad possibilities. Also beef BBQ always calls for ketchup. More and more possibilities!

    reply to this comment

  3. Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (10)Json Example

    This looks delicious!!!

    reply to this comment

  4. Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (11)Andrea

    Need to make this! Putting it on my to do list!

    reply to this comment

  5. Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (12)Rachel

    Could the maple syrup be substituted with a sugar free sweetener, such as organic Stevia or monk fruit? Or, is the stickiness and extra liquid needed for this to come out right? Ty!

    reply to this comment

Leave a Comment

Easy Peasy Paleo Ketchup Recipe - Empowered Sustenance (2024)

FAQs

What's the difference between sauce and ketchup? ›

Ketchup primarily consists of tomatoes, vinegar, sugar, and spices. On the other hand, sauce can have a broader range of ingredients, including fruits, vegetables, herbs, spices, and sometimes even meat or seafood, creating a more diverse flavour profile.

Can you eat ketchup on Paleo diet? ›

Aside from a few specialty organic brands, almost no commercially-available ketchup is Paleo. It should be noted that tomatoes are classified as a member of the nightshade family, a class of foods that can cause inflammation or other adverse reactions in some people.

Was ketchup used as a medicine? ›

Ketchup Was Medicine At Some Point

In the 1830s, tomato ketchup was sold as a medicine that could cure ailments like diarrhea, indigestion, and jaundice. The idea was initially proposed by Dr. John Cook Bennett, an American physician, in 1834, who later decided to sell the recipe in the form of 'tomato pills'.

What do Australians call catsup? ›

Ketchup is underrated. We call it tomato sauce in Australia.

What's the difference between ketchup and SOS? ›

To make it simpler, ketchup is made with a variety of spices while the sauce is generally made without spices. Another major point of difference between the tomato sauce and ketchup is, sauce generally does not contain sugar while ketchup has a specific amount of sugar and other sweet spices.

Is any cheese allowed on Paleo? ›

A Paleo-diet purist will tell you no, all cheese should be avoided on a Paleo lifestyle. Paleolithic humans didn't milk cows or process dairy. This is one case in which keto diet rules are much more lax than paleo.

Is ketchup an inflammatory food? ›

Research suggests any of ketchup's health benefits likely come from the carotenoid lycopene in the tomatoes. Lycopene itself is believed to have anticancer, anti-inflammatory, and antidiabetic properties, yet there's little research to suggest that eating ketchup itself will have the same effects ( 1 , 4 ).

What did ketchup used to be called? ›

Early uses in English. The word entered the English language in Britain during the late 17th century, appearing in print as catchup (1690) and later as ketchup (1711). The following is a list of early quotations collected by the Oxford English Dictionary. "Catchup: a high East-India Sauce."

What was ketchup originally invented for? ›

In the early 19 century, tomato ketchup was sold in pharmacies as a medicine for diarrhea and indigestion. During that period, farmers primarily prepared ketchup and were happy to find another way of conserving tomatoes.

What food was ketchup originally made for? ›

Like Worcestershire sauce, which emerged during the following century, the ketchups of the mid-1700s were typically used as catch-all flavor enhancers for gravies and sauces for fish dishes. The fish-based ketchups often included anchovies, but Smith notes that co*ckle, mussel, and oyster ketchups were common, too.

Why should ketchup not be refrigerated? ›

In addition, Sargent adds, to the preservative natures of the vinegar, salt, and sweeteners, “the acidity of the tomatoes prevent it from requiring refrigeration, but the flavor and texture will be better maintained if kept under refrigerated conditions.”

Should you refrigerate ketchup? ›

This is because, just like pickles, the flavor and texture declines after you open the bottle or jar and the ketchup is exposed to air. To slow down this process way down, stash it in the fridge. This keeps your ketchup tasting salty, savory, sweet, tangy, and perfectly tomato-y.

Should I freeze ketchup? ›

Ketchup – If you are like me and only use ketchup on occasion, you can freeze most of it. Spoon the ketchup into ice trays and freeze so you can easily pop some out when needed. When it is time to warm it back up, just put the container under some hot water.

Is ketchup technically a sauce? ›

Did you know that while all ketchup is technically tomato sauce, not all tomato sauce is ketchup? The same goes for chutneys, passata, relishes and other tomato sauces.

Is ketchup considered sauce? ›

Both! You can use as a condiment, however it is a sauce technically because it has a few cooked and blended ingredients. You also can cook with it. Meat loaf is a lonely dish without ketchup.

What makes a sauce a ketchup? ›

The unmodified term ("ketchup") now typically refers to tomato ketchup, although early recipes for various different varieties of ketchup contained mushrooms, oysters, mussels, egg whites, grapes or walnuts, among other ingredients. Tomato ketchup is made from tomatoes, sugar, and vinegar, with seasonings and spices.

Why is it called ketchup not tomato sauce? ›

Most historians do believe that the word is almost certainly of Chinese origin, but that it more likely stems from kê-tsiap, a word from Hokkien that refers to fish sauce.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Domingo Moore

Last Updated:

Views: 5461

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Domingo Moore

Birthday: 1997-05-20

Address: 6485 Kohler Route, Antonioton, VT 77375-0299

Phone: +3213869077934

Job: Sales Analyst

Hobby: Kayaking, Roller skating, Cabaret, Rugby, Homebrewing, Creative writing, amateur radio

Introduction: My name is Domingo Moore, I am a attractive, gorgeous, funny, jolly, spotless, nice, fantastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.